Tech & Gadgets · Head-to-head
Silver Ticket STR-169120 120-inch Fixed Frame vs VividStorm ALR Fixed Frame Obsidian Long Throw Screen
Which should you buy? Our verdict on both, pulled from our full The Best Projector Screens: 4 Compared (and One to Skip) comparison.
For most people with a room they can darken, the Silver Ticket fixed frame delivers the best picture per dollar and a rock-steady surface. If you cannot control the light, the VividStorm ALR screen is the runner-up that keeps contrast intact.
Silver Ticket STR-169120 120-inch Fixed Frame
Buy itA drum-tight, color-neutral fixed frame that has been the value benchmark for home theater for years.
- Rod-in-pocket tensioning pulls the surface flat and, per the maker, removes puckers and wrinkles
- Neutral 1.1-gain white material renders accurate color that owners often praise
- Velvet-wrapped aluminum frame absorbs overspill and looks like a permanent installation
- Permanent wall mount only, so it cannot be hidden or moved
- Assembly of the six-piece frame takes patience and a helper
VividStorm ALR Fixed Frame Obsidian Long Throw Screen
Buy itAn ambient-light-rejecting screen that keeps contrast alive when you cannot fully darken the room.
- Obsidian ALR material is built to reject overhead and side light, so the image stays punchier in a lit room
- Noticeably deeper blacks and better perceived contrast than a plain white screen in ambient light
- Rigid fixed frame designed for standard and long-throw projectors
- Costs well more than a plain white fixed frame of the same size
- The grey surface trims a little peak brightness and rewards a brighter projector
Side by side
The 7 criteria below are the ones our full comparison judged every product on, narrowed to these two.
| Silver Ticket STR-169120 120-inch Fixed Frame Our pick | VividStorm ALR Fixed Frame Obsidian Long Throw Screen | |
|---|---|---|
| Our verdict | Buy | Buy |
| Best for | A dedicated or light-controlled room where the screen can stay up and picture quality per dollar matters most. | Living rooms and multipurpose spaces with windows or lamps you cannot fully control. |
| Price tier | $$ · mid-range | $$$ · premium |
| Screen type | Fixed frame | ALR fixed frame |
| Best room | Dark / controlled room | Room with ambient light |
| Surface flatness | Excellent (rod-tensioned) | Excellent (rigid frame) |
| Ambient light handling | Needs a dark room | Rejects much of the stray light |
| Install / permanence | Permanent wall mount | Permanent wall mount |
| Setup effort | Moderate (frame assembly) | Moderate (frame assembly) |
| Best for | Picture-per-dollar | Bright rooms |
Which one is right for you?
Pick the Silver Ticket STR-169120 120-inch Fixed Frame if
a dedicated or light-controlled room where the screen can stay up and picture quality per dollar matters most.
Know before buying: permanent wall mount only, so it cannot be hidden or moved.
Pick the VividStorm ALR Fixed Frame Obsidian Long Throw Screen if
living rooms and multipurpose spaces with windows or lamps you cannot fully control.
Know before buying: costs well more than a plain white fixed frame of the same size.
The bottom line
Our overall pick is the Silver Ticket STR-169120 120-inch Fixed Frame - A drum-tight, color-neutral fixed frame that has been the value benchmark for home theater for years. Choose the VividStorm ALR Fixed Frame Obsidian Long Throw Screen instead if living rooms and multipurpose spaces with windows or lamps you cannot fully control.
Want the full picture, including the other options we compared and the popular one we'd skip? Read the complete The Best Projector Screens: 4 Compared (and One to Skip).