Home & Kitchen · Head-to-head
OXO Good Grips Cookie Press with Disk Storage Case vs Wilton Simple Success Cookie Press, 13-Piece
Which should you buy? Our verdict on both, pulled from our full The Best Cookie Presses: 6 Compared (and One to Skip) comparison.
The OXO is the easiest to load and clean, with a ratcheting lever and mostly dishwasher-safe parts. The Wilton gives the same 12-shape range at a budget tier if you are happy to hand wash.
OXO Good Grips Cookie Press with Disk Storage Case
Buy itA ratcheting lever, a quick-release plunger and a mostly dishwasher-safe body make it the easiest press here to load and clean.
- The ratcheting lever releases one cookie per pump, so the dough count stays predictable from the first cookie to the last.
- The barrel, bottom ring and 12 stainless steel disks are listed as dishwasher safe in the maker's booklet.
- A clear barrel, a non-slip base and a storage case for the disks round out a well-thought-out kit.
- The top and plunger are hand wash only, so it is not a full toss-it-in-the-dishwasher tool.
- Twelve disks is fewer than the 20-disc metal presses, though extra seasonal disk sets are sold separately.
- The maker says it is not recommended for store-bought refrigerated dough, so you need a proper room-temperature spritz dough.
Wilton Simple Success Cookie Press, 13-Piece
Buy itA trigger press with a clear barrel and 12 discs, and the cheapest way into spritz cookies here.
- The soft-touch trigger and ergonomic handle are built for the repetitive squeeze a big batch needs.
- The ultra-clear barrel shows when the dough is running low.
- Twelve discs cover classic spritz shapes plus seasonal ones like a pumpkin, turkey, wreath and snowman.
- Wilton's page says to wash in warm, soapy water and does not list dishwasher safety.
- The page does not state the barrel or disc material.
- The listing does not describe how loading works or include a storage case for the discs.
Side by side
The 8 criteria below are the ones our full comparison judged every product on, narrowed to these two.
| OXO Good Grips Cookie Press with Disk Storage Case Our pick | Wilton Simple Success Cookie Press, 13-Piece | |
|---|---|---|
| Our verdict | Buy | Buy |
| Best for | First-time spritz bakers who want the least fuss from loading to cleanup. | Casual holiday bakers who want a full set of shapes without spending much. |
| Price tier | $$ · mid-range | $ · budget |
| Press action | Ratcheting lever (one pump per cookie) | Soft-touch trigger |
| Discs or shapes | 12 stainless steel disks | 12 discs |
| Icing tips | None listed | None listed |
| Body material | Not stated; clear barrel, stainless disks | Not stated; clear barrel |
| Dishwasher guidance | Barrel, ring and disks yes; top and plunger hand wash | Wash in warm soapy water |
| See dough level | Yes, clear barrel | Yes, clear barrel |
| Disc storage | Storage case included | Not listed |
| Warranty or guarantee | Satisfaction guarantee | Not stated |
Which one is right for you?
Pick the OXO Good Grips Cookie Press with Disk Storage Case if
first-time spritz bakers who want the least fuss from loading to cleanup.
Know before buying: the top and plunger are hand wash only, so it is not a full toss-it-in-the-dishwasher tool.
Pick the Wilton Simple Success Cookie Press, 13-Piece if
casual holiday bakers who want a full set of shapes without spending much.
Know before buying: wilton's page says to wash in warm, soapy water and does not list dishwasher safety.
The bottom line
Our overall pick is the OXO Good Grips Cookie Press with Disk Storage Case - A ratcheting lever, a quick-release plunger and a mostly dishwasher-safe body make it the easiest press here to load and clean. Choose the Wilton Simple Success Cookie Press, 13-Piece instead if casual holiday bakers who want a full set of shapes without spending much.
Want the full picture, including the other options we compared and the popular one we'd skip? Read the complete The Best Cookie Presses: 6 Compared (and One to Skip).