Automotive · Head-to-head
Lusso Gear XL Car Trash Can (3.5 Gallon) vs EPAuto Waterproof Car Trash Can with Lid and Pockets
Which should you buy? Our verdict on both, pulled from our full The Best Car Trash Cans: 4 Compared (and One to Skip) comparison.
The Lusso Gear XL is the one to buy if the bin is staying in the car permanently: it stands up on its own, contains odors, mounts several ways, and the removable liner makes emptying quick. The EPAuto covers the same essentials, a waterproof interior and a closing lid, at the budget tier, and it is the smarter choice for lighter trash loads or a second vehicle.
Lusso Gear XL Car Trash Can (3.5 Gallon)
Buy itThe bin here built to stand up on its own whether it is empty or stuffed, with a liner you lift out without unclipping anything.
- Reinforced sides and bottom keep it square when empty and stop it bulging when full
- Removable leakproof liner empties in seconds while the bin stays mounted
- Flip-top lid with overlapping edges keeps trash and odor contained on the move
- Mounts on a headrest, a car seat, around a console, or on the floorboard
- Physically large, so it competes for footwell space in small cars
- Premium tier pricing for a fabric bin
- Console strap needs shortening and re-checking on wider center consoles
EPAuto Waterproof Car Trash Can with Lid and Pockets
Buy itGets the two things that matter right, a sealed interior and a lid that closes, for the least money in the category.
- Waterproof lining that wipes clean
- Fold-over lid with an elastic opening hides trash and still takes a cup one-handed
- Straps handle a seatback, console, glovebox or floor, with grip pads on the base
- Mesh side pockets and a front pocket for wipes and sanitizer
- Soft walls lean inward until there is enough inside to hold the shape
- Elastic opening is narrower than an open-top bin, so bulky containers are a squeeze
- One size and one color, with no larger option in the range
Side by side
The 7 criteria below are the ones our full comparison judged every product on, narrowed to these two.
| Lusso Gear XL Car Trash Can (3.5 Gallon) Our pick | EPAuto Waterproof Car Trash Can with Lid and Pockets | |
|---|---|---|
| Our verdict | Buy | Buy |
| Best for | Families and road trippers who want one permanent bin that holds a full day of trash and resists slumping. | Commuters, second cars, and anyone who wants a lidded leakproof bin without spending much. |
| Price tier | $$$ · premium | $ · budget |
| Capacity | 3.5 gallons | 2.5 gallons |
| Lid or closure | Flip-top with overlapping edges | Fold-over lid with elastic opening |
| Leak protection | Removable leakproof liner | Waterproof lining |
| Holds shape when empty | Yes, reinforced sides and base | Partly, soft sides lean in |
| Mounting options | Headrest, seat, console strap, floorboard | Headrest, console, glovebox, floor grips |
| Storage pockets | Mesh side pockets and front zip pocket | Mesh side pockets and front pocket |
| Emptying | Lift the liner, bin stays mounted | Lift by side handles or pull the liner |
Which one is right for you?
Pick the Lusso Gear XL Car Trash Can (3.5 Gallon) if
families and road trippers who want one permanent bin that holds a full day of trash and resists slumping.
Know before buying: physically large, so it competes for footwell space in small cars.
Pick the EPAuto Waterproof Car Trash Can with Lid and Pockets if
commuters, second cars, and anyone who wants a lidded leakproof bin without spending much.
Know before buying: soft walls lean inward until there is enough inside to hold the shape.
The bottom line
Our overall pick is the Lusso Gear XL Car Trash Can (3.5 Gallon) - The bin here built to stand up on its own whether it is empty or stuffed, with a liner you lift out without unclipping anything. Choose the EPAuto Waterproof Car Trash Can with Lid and Pockets instead if commuters, second cars, and anyone who wants a lidded leakproof bin without spending much.
Want the full picture, including the other options we compared and the popular one we'd skip? Read the complete The Best Car Trash Cans: 4 Compared (and One to Skip).